Thanks Alice for hosting a fine book club last Friday, lovely to see you back !

We had found Amelia Earhart a bit of a disappointment and a missed opportunity — she seems to be such a fascinating character that the sentimental romantic story she ended up in with Noonan, and the overblown language (‘the sky is flesh’ ??) didn’t do justice to her life story which had potential to be turned into so much more.  Some good bits including the flying scenes inside the aircraft, and a brief acknowledgement of her actual achievements sadly didn’t make the book into the classic it could have been.  The theories around her actual disappearance are interesting, including that they did land on a deserted island, and sent radio messages which were dismissed as a hoax, they ditched into the sea or were captured by the Japanese!  Either way, the reality seems to be better than the fiction.

Reading for next time:

Friday 12 May — Travels with my Aunt by Graham Greene

Friday 9 June – What I Talk About When I Talk About Running by Haruki Murakami

Choosing next for July meeting :  Emma

May meeting is Rachel’s farewell to Gibson Gardens and will be at Ruth’s flat (76).  Sorry I won’t be able to make it as am off on holiday, but hope you have a great book club!


Thanks Steve for excellent hosting (crisps in a bowl!) and a great book club last Friday.

We enjoyed Julia’s stories of episodes from her life, introduced using the animals and pets she had over the years.  It was a good technique to give you a glimpse into her difficult childhood and family life but without directly telling the story as misery-lit.  Most of us found it a light touch way to show her relationships with her parents and their chaotic sounding lives, although the shortness of the book, whilst appreciated, did mean a lot was missed out.  Steve tells us that following this, JB wrote a full memoir of her life with her parents, The Three of Us,  so this was perhaps her introduction and way into writing more about her family.

This book shouldn’t be confused with Claire Balding’s memoir with the same title.  One nameless booker may have read and not enjoyed that by mistake…..

Details for next time:

Thursday 13 April – I was Amelia Earhart by Jane Mendelsohn

Friday 12 May – Travels with my Aunt by Graham Greene

Choosing next – Candida

This looks really cool!  But I can’t make either of the dates.  Anyway, in case anyone is interested in a timely show to accompany the book for April::


Mark Harvey (@Mwharvey)
Amelia Earhart Social Worker oh and pioneer, role model, world renowned pilot & explorer. #foundationsofSW #IWD2017 pic.twitter.com/heCED7BIDY

Thanks all for coming round for a fab anniversary book club last week.  It’s a long post this month but we had a lot to get through…..

First up, the book of choice.  We’d all been left in the dark by Ubik and tried to work out between us exactly what had been going on.  It was a mishmash of lots of ideas and characters which arrived but didn’t go anywhere, and seemed like the product of a lot of drugs.  Some fun bits, including descriptions of the amazing outfits everyone would be wearing in 1992, and some of his predictions of technology, but overall it was confused and odd, and probably not Phil’s best.  Anyone who thinks he is worth trying again could go with Sian’s recommendation of Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? on which Bladerunner was based, or The Man in the High Castle, currently a TV series.

Next up, the raffle, which was won by Emma this year — congratulations and pleased to hear it’s been put to good use already on some poetry books.

Then on to the much anticipated quiz, and it was congratulations to Emma again, the reigning champion got an excellent 23/25 to make it 2 winning years in a row.  Highly commended to Ruth in second, Candida in third, and Steve and Sian for some good guesses.

Review of the year turned contentious with everyone allowed a vote, even those who hadn’t read any of the books… despite that I think the right books still came out on top, with the final results::  1. New Finnish Grammar, 2. Beware of Pity, 3. Fahrenheit 451.  Rotten tomato of the year to Wings of the Dove, closely followed by Ubik.

Just time for a reveal of the next book:

Friday 10 March — My Animals and Other Family by Julia Blackburn

Thursday 13 April — I was Amelia Earhart by Jane Mendelsohn

Please note change of date in April as it’s Easter weekend!

We then moved on to Brian’s hummus and innuendos which will be turned into a song for the March meeting 😁

Finally finally — Rachel will be choosing next for May book club.

Thanks Ruth for hosting a fine January book club.

Sweet Caress had positives and negatives — the voice of Amory was very immediate and distinctive, drawing you straight into her world and life as a photographer.  The incident with her father, which shaped her life, was very well done and really did set the scene for the rest of her life.  However the predominance of Amory’s voice was less good if you didn’t like Amory much or care what happened to her.  Another section which seemed badly done was her trip to Vietnam, which stood out as very unbelievable, in a book which otherwise rang pretty true.  Debate as to whether the inclusion of photos added to the book or not, on the whole we weren’t too fussed about them.  All agreed he is a very good writer and there was lots to like.  Other William Boyd recommendations for fans are: Brazzaville Beach about primate research, and An Ice Cream War, set in East Africa at the end of WW1.

Details for next time:

Friday 10 Feb — Ubik by Philip K Dick

Friday 10 March — My Animals and Other Family by Julia Blackburn

February is the anniversary so don’t forget £2 for the raffle!  And there will be other anniversary activity including review of the year, 2017 quiz, and a musical interlude.

looking forward to it!

Thanks for coming round on the 9th for a cosy evening of chat and books.

Altai started off well – with spies running around Dubrovnik and Constantinople, a fire in the Venetian Arsenale, and a baddie with a hidden heart of gold.  Sounds good so far?  And it was, a lot of plot, short chapters, made it quite a breathless page turner.  A story of the persecution of Jews in various parts of Europe, and a powerful family who wanted to create a Jewish homeland, intertwined with the personal story of Manuel Cardoso, alias Emanuel de Zante, converted Jew and spy.  However the last third or so of the book, which told of an alliance with the Ottoman empire to attack and capture Cyprus from their Venetian rivals, degenerated into an orgy of violence and nastiness.  Whilst it was probably quite accurate about the absolute horror of a bloody and long battle, it made for disturbing and difficult reading.  Emma thought it was a male book, but I’m not sure our peace loving men of book club would have liked it either.  Some interesting parallels with the Israel/Palestine conflict today, the book was based on real events, and perhaps a warning from history.

Details for next months:

Friday 13th January — Sweet Caress by William Boyd

Friday 10th February — Ubik by Philip K Dick

February is also the anniversary meeting, we are 14, sulky teenager phase.  I am planning the quiz for this year – as a teaser, I’ll just say it will have similarities to last year, so everyone should be able to get at least a few right, but it won’t be easy to get them all!  No more clues for now, but get swotting, only about 6 weeks before everyone tries to beat reigning champ Emma.  We will also have another raffle – don’t forget to bring £2 – and a review of our year of reading.

Last thing, there is an upcoming production of The Heart of a Dog, which we read a couple of years ago.  Its on at the Arcola in February , I suggest going on Thursday 9th February.  If anyone is interested I’m happy to book tickets, they’re a bargain £10, so let me know.